The Church Co positions itself as a premium, all-in-one platform for churches that want beautiful design without the hassle of piecing together separate tools. It combines a website builder, mobile app, giving, communication, and church management into a single dashboard. The pitch is compelling. But is it the right choice for your church?
We evaluated The Church Co across design quality, features, ease of use, pricing transparency, and how it compares to alternatives like Tithe.ly and Squarespace. Here’s our honest assessment.
In This Guide
Quick Verdict
The Church Co delivers the best-looking church websites of any church-specific platform. If design is your top priority and you want everything under one roof, it’s worth a look. But opaque pricing, a smaller ecosystem, and limited third-party integrations make it hard to recommend over more established alternatives — especially for small and mid-sized churches watching their budget.
What The Church Co Does Well
Design Quality
This is The Church Co’s strongest selling point, and it’s not close. Their websites look like they were designed by a professional agency — clean typography, sophisticated layouts, intentional whitespace, and photography-forward design. Most church-specific platforms produce websites that look like church websites. The Church Co produces websites that look like modern brand websites that happen to be for churches.
The templates use contemporary design patterns: full-bleed hero images, scroll-based animations, elegant font pairings, and color schemes that feel curated rather than default. If your church values visual excellence and wants a website that reflects the quality of your Sunday morning experience, The Church Co delivers.
Unified Dashboard
Everything lives in one place: website management, giving, communication, events, groups, check-in, and analytics. You don’t need separate logins for your website builder, giving platform, email tool, and church management system. For church staff managing multiple tools across multiple platforms, the consolidation is genuinely valuable.
The dashboard is well-designed — consistent interface, logical navigation, and modern UI. Your admin experience matches the polish of the public-facing website, which isn’t true of every platform.
Custom Church App
The Church Co includes a branded mobile app as part of their platform. The app connects to the same backend as your website, so content updates appear in both places. For churches that want an app without the separate cost and management overhead, this is a solid inclusion.
The app includes push notifications, sermon access, event information, giving, and group communication. It’s not as feature-rich as a standalone app from Subsplash, but it covers the essentials and comes included rather than as an expensive add-on.
Sermon Management
Sermon management is built in and handles audio, video, notes, and series organization. The sermon pages look professional, with series artwork, speaker filtering, and clean playback interfaces. If your church publishes sermons regularly, the built-in tools are more than adequate. For general best practices, see our sermon archive guide.
Where The Church Co Falls Short
Opaque Pricing
This is the biggest frustration. The Church Co doesn’t publish pricing on their website. You have to book a demo call to get a quote. In 2026, this is a red flag for many churches — leadership teams want to compare costs before committing to a sales conversation.
Based on reported pricing from churches who’ve gone through the process, The Church Co is significantly more expensive than alternatives. Expect costs in the $150-300+/month range depending on church size and features selected. That’s 3-10x what you’d pay for Tithe.ly or Squarespace, and competitive with (or more than) Subsplash.
For a broader cost comparison, see our church website cost guide.
Smaller Ecosystem
The Church Co is a smaller company compared to Tithe.ly, Subsplash, or the general-purpose builders. That means fewer template options, a smaller user community, less third-party documentation, and fewer people who can troubleshoot issues. If your current website volunteer leaves and you need to find a replacement, it’s easier to find someone who knows Squarespace or WordPress than someone who knows The Church Co.
Limited Third-Party Integrations
Because The Church Co wants to be your everything platform, it doesn’t prioritize integrations with external tools. If your church uses Planning Center, Mailchimp, or other established church tools, you may find the integration options limited or nonexistent. The platform works best when you go all-in on their ecosystem — which is a significant commitment.
Vendor Lock-In Risk
When your website, app, giving, communication, and church management all live on one platform, switching becomes extremely painful. If pricing increases, features change, or the company direction shifts, you’re facing a complete platform migration across every ministry function. With separate tools, you can swap one at a time.
The Church Co vs. Alternatives
| Feature | The Church Co | Tithe.ly | Squarespace |
|---|---|---|---|
| Design quality | Excellent | Good | Excellent |
| Church-specific features | Yes (all-in-one) | Yes (all-in-one) | No (general purpose) |
| Mobile app | Included | Available (paid) | None |
| Online giving | Built-in | Built-in | Third-party needed |
| Sermon management | Built-in | Built-in | Manual (blog workaround) |
| Pricing transparency | Quote required | Published online | Published online |
| Starting cost | ~$150+/mo (estimated) | Free tier available | $16/mo |
| Third-party integrations | Limited | Good | Excellent |
| Ease of handoff | Moderate | Easy | Easy |
| Community/ecosystem size | Small | Large | Very large |
Who Should Consider The Church Co
- Churches that prioritize design above all else and have the budget to match
- Mid-to-large churches (500+ attendance) that want one platform for everything
- Churches willing to commit fully to a single ecosystem without external tools
- Churches with dedicated staff (not just volunteers) managing their digital presence
Who Should Look Elsewhere
- Small churches or church plants — The cost is prohibitive and the features are overkill
- Budget-conscious churches — Tithe.ly offers similar church-specific features at a fraction of the cost
- Churches using Planning Center — Limited integration means duplicate data entry
- Churches wanting pricing transparency — If you can’t get a price without a sales call, that’s a values mismatch for many church cultures
Our Verdict
The Church Co is the best-looking church-specific website platform available. Full stop. If design quality is your deciding factor and money isn’t a constraint, it delivers. But for the vast majority of churches, the combination of opaque pricing, limited integrations, vendor lock-in risk, and a smaller ecosystem makes it difficult to recommend over Tithe.ly (for church-specific features on a budget) or Squarespace (for design quality at a transparent price).
If The Church Co published their pricing and improved their integration options, our recommendation would change. Until then, we suggest starting with a more transparent platform and upgrading only if you hit limitations those platforms can’t solve. For a full comparison of all your options, see our best church website builders guide.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much does The Church Co cost?
The Church Co doesn’t publish pricing. You need to schedule a demo and receive a custom quote based on your church’s size and needs. Based on reported pricing from churches who’ve used the platform, expect $150-300+ per month. This includes the website, app, giving, and church management tools — but it’s significantly more than alternatives like Tithe.ly (starting free) or Squarespace ($16/month).
Does The Church Co include online giving?
Yes, online giving is built into the platform. It includes recurring giving, text-to-give, and giving analytics. The giving tools are integrated with the website and app, so donors have a seamless experience. However, The Church Co’s giving processing fees should be compared to standalone giving platforms before committing. For more on this topic, see our online giving guide.
Can I migrate from The Church Co to another platform?
Yes, but it’s painful. Because The Church Co houses your website, app, giving, communication, and church management, migrating means moving everything at once. Your giving history, member data, sermon archives, and website content would all need to be exported and rebuilt elsewhere. This is the trade-off of an all-in-one platform. Consider this carefully before signing a contract.
Is The Church Co better than Tithe.ly?
The Church Co has better website design quality. Tithe.ly has better pricing transparency, a larger ecosystem, more integrations, and a free tier. For most churches — especially those under 500 in attendance — Tithe.ly is the more practical choice. The Church Co wins on aesthetics; Tithe.ly wins on value and accessibility.
Does The Church Co require a contract?
Terms vary based on your agreement, but many churches report annual contracts with The Church Co. Ask specifically about contract length, cancellation terms, and data export options during your demo call. Any platform asking for a long-term commitment should be able to clearly explain what happens to your data if you leave.
Leave a Reply